top of page
2026 Reviews


Lovers and Madmen Alike Will Adore “A Midsummer Night’s Dream:” For The Whim’s Production is Nobly Discharged
by Don Toal Some stories never fall out of fashion. The ones who we know by heart but always appreciate revisiting. They’re like an old friend where, upon sharing the same space together after who knows how long, it feels as though no time has passed. Shakespeare’s canon of plays occupies that cultural space for many artists and their supporters. If produced with care and love, these plays and the language that defines them remains timeless, and for damn good reason. Wh


Clear Away the Cobwebs and the Sorrow in the Levoy’s Production of Annie
by Ellorah Maeve The opportunity to see this musical classic, Annie, is always an enjoyable experience. This is especially true at The Levoy Theatre. Having the opportunity to give gifts to castmates, buy concessions, and even specialty themed cocktails make the night even more magical. The musical Annie is about the titular character, an eleven year-old orphan girl who finds herself in the mansion of billionaire Oliver Warbucks to spend the holidays. There are many songs su


The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical at Bridge Players Theatre Company Delivers Joy
by Shirley Erwin With holiday favorites playing overhead and audience members donning festive sweaters, the Christmas ambiance hits you as soon as you step into Broad Street United Methodist Church in Burlington. The Bridge Players Theatre Company continues to celebrate its 50th Anniversary Season with a delightful production of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical. Based on the beloved book and subsequent play by Barbara Robinson, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever was


Pit Stop: A Juicy Journey with James and the Giant Peach at Players Club of Swarthmore
by Lindsey DeVol “We are now about to visit the most marvelous places and see the most wonderful things!” — Roald Dahl, James and the Giant Peach The world of James and the Giant Peach has always held a very special place in my heart. From the first time I saw it at six years old to the summer I assistant-directed a junior production of the show, it has always been a story that sweeps me off my feet and straight back to the feelings of childlike wonder that we are all crav


1776: A Nation Divided, A Future Undecided at the Kelsey Theatre
by Michael McKeon I hate to bring politics into any conversation, let alone one of my reviews for South Jersey Theatre Critics (SJTC). However, I think if there was ever a time to do so, the justified opportunity would be during my review of 1776 The Musical. 1776 The Musical, I saw for the first time on Saturday Afternoon. Performed inside Kelsey Theatre at Mercer Community College, produced by Theater To Go and directed by Ruth Markoe. Stage Managed by Christine Heffron w


Living for Today: Old Academy Players Takes on Rent
by Abby Williams There’s no musical I’d rather kick off the holiday season more than Rent. You may be wondering, “Rent isn’t a Christmas musical?” To that I say, of course it is a Christmas musical. Yes, I know it’s November! However, I still feel the Christmas spirit. After all, “Christmas bells are riiinnnginngggg, Christmas bells are riiinnnginngggg!” Rent has always had a special place in my heart. I remember walking through the halls as a high school student blasting fa


You Can Be Smart, Or You Can Be Pleasant, Or Hear Me Out, You Can Be Both When You Support Gateway Playhouse
by Deitra Oliver Most of us can point to someone in our lives whom we might consider a little bit different or eccentric. Maybe you have an aunt who will only wear green from head-to-toe, a friend who is a hobby horse racing champion, or a cousin who regularly greets you in Dothraki. It doesn’t matter what the hobby or personality quirk is; we all know someone. Harvey, a 1944 play by Mary Chase, tells the story of Elwood P. Dowd, who has a six-foot-three-and-a-half-inch b


Flowers and Passion a-bloomin’ at Rose Cottagein SCTC’s “Sex Please, We’re Sixty”
by April Johnson This past weekend I made a trip to South Camden Theater to check out the last show of 2026’s season Sex Please, We’re Sixty. The anchor of SCTC’s 21st season, Sex Please is an uproarious production that deserves sold out performances from now to close. “At South Camden Theatre Company, we believe that humor is a powerful tool for hope and connection—especially during challenging times. Our theme, “LAUGHING THROUGH THE STORM,” reminds us that laughter is not


Horror, Humor, and the Duty of Storytellers: The Pillowman at Cumberland Players
by Laura Duffy For a lighthearted, relaxing evening at the theatre, do not seek out The Pillowman at Cumberland Players (as the director warns in the program). To witness a gripping, impressive performance from eight remarkable actors led by a staunchly devoted creative team, buy your tickets immediately. Written by Irish filmmaker and playwright Martin McDonagh, The Pillowman follows fiction writer Katurian as he is interrogated about a series of gruesome child murders in


Stumble On In: The Drowsy Chaperone is a Toast-Worthy Treat at Burlington County Footlighters
by Piper Byrne We all have one. It’s the cast album we put on after a long day, the overture that makes us sit up a little straighter, the show we know every beat of and still can’t stop loving. For me, it’s Guys and Dolls. For the Man in Chair, it’s a long-forgotten 1928 musical comedy called The Drowsy Chaperone. And at Burlington County Footlighters, he invites all of us into his apartment to love it right along with him. The Drowsy Chaperone, with music and lyrics by L


Come to New Jersey to see The Philadelphia Story at The Village Playbox
by: Megan Guy Set in the countryside near Philadelphia in late June 1939, The Philadelphia Story, directed by Steve Allen, assisted by John Blackwell, presents a charming take on the classic romantic comedy detailing the lives of the Lord family over the course of two days leading up to daughter Tracy Lord’s wedding day. Under Allen's dual leadership in direction and set design, the well-constructed staging and period-appropriate furnishings effectively capture the sophist


Celluloid Meets Reality at the Ritz Theatre Company for Rocky Horror Picture Show
by: Amber Stolarski This Halloween, I trekked across the bridge for a late night picture show- The Rocky Horror Picture Show, which played for a short set of performances at the Ritz Theatre Company in Oaklyn, NJ, at the end of October. The Ritz's aesthetic really lends itself to a showing of RHPS-- the classic red curtain with a mind-bending linear projection splayed across. The proscenium was done up to evoke the image of a vintage movie theater. This production was done


Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike - You Are Never Past Your Prime
by Elizabeth Holzworth Karen Johnston opens her director’s note with “there don’t seem to be many ‘coming-of-middle-age’ stories.” While seeing the show this past Sunday November 1st, I sat in the audience and tried to think of one off the top of my head. I couldn't. That is precisely why I walked out of their production of this Christopher Durang show so inspired. It was nothing like I thought it would be, in the best way possible. Directed by Karen Johnston and produced by


The Rocky Horror Show: Blue Moon Theater
by Talia Walters My favorite part about walking into smaller performance spaces is the fact that the productions held there never cease to impress. Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horror Show (directed by Mike Russell), currently playing at Blue Moon Theater, is no exception. Everything from the explicit humor to the enthusiastic audience participation makes this show such a fun night out especially for the Halloween season. The Rocky Horror Show follows a newly engaged couple,


A Bloody Good Time: Evil Dead: The Musical
by Lucinda Fisher Alvarez There are musicals that aim to move an audience, musicals that inspire, and musicals that simply invite everyone to sit back and enjoy the ride. In Death’s Company’s Evil Dead: The Musical at Kelsey Theatre falls firmly into the third category and that is precisely where its appeal lies. Combining campy horror, outrageous humor, energetic musical numbers, and plenty of theatrical bloodshed, this production delivers an entertaining evening that emb


It’s a New Dawn at the Kelsey Theatre, and I’m Feeling Good
by Deitra Oliver Being part of South Jersey Theater Critics has allowed me to experience many wonderful productions and support the theater community with reviews I hope are encouraging and helpful. Community theater is a labor of love, with cast and crew members giving their time, energy, and talents, often for nothing more than their love of the craft. I love seeing the passion and dedication brought to each stage as people live out their dreams. This past July, I was fort


Celebrate the Significance of Theatre with Trolls and Men at The Ritz
by Shannon Red In the 1867 play Peer Gynt, the troll king asks Peer Gynt “What is the difference between trolls and men?” While at first Peer Gent notes that there is no difference because both humans and trolls will do what their leader asks, the troll king goes on to share that the difference lies in humans’ ability to be true to themselves with moral reasoning and independent thinking. This scene movingly portrayed in Trolls and Men by Alex Wilke currently on stage at the


Put That Bass In Your Walk and Run To “The Legend of Georgia McBride” at Players Club of Swarthmore
by Amber Stolarski “What does it mean to pursue your dreams? What is the weight of a true ‘American dream’?” Director Max Segarnick’s thoughtful director’s note asks audiences to consider this question as we prepare to watch Players’ Club of Swarthmore’s production of The Legend of Georgia McBride by Matthew López, now playing on the company’s Second Stage through October 18th. My journey to this evening’s destination of Cleo’s, a dive bar in Panama City Beach, Florida,


Little Women at Kelsey Theatre in association with Off-Centre Stages
by Addison Geisler Though first published in 1868, Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women continues to resonate with audiences, finding new life in its musical adaptation. Off-Centre Stages brings this beloved coming-of-age story to the Kelsey Theatre, directed by MJ Santry and produced by Jonathan Edmondson. Exploring sisterhood, ambition, and the bittersweet process of growing up, Little Women: The Musical invites audiences to rediscover the March family’s enduring story. With m


The Atlantic City Theater Company Takes You Somewhere That’s Green
by Deitra Oliver If you are receiving this transmission, it means the giant plant monsters haven’t taken over yet, and there’s still time for you to see The Atlantic City Theater Company’s production of Little Shop of Horrors. Playing at the Resorts Casino and Hotel Theater, this production offers an opportunity to live it up this spooky season and possibly make a weekend of it, as I did. Little Shop of Horrors is a personal favorite of my mother, so I was excited to take h


Dear Sugar…
by Sarah Dorsey I would be the worst thespian if I did not warn you to BUY YOUR TICKET NOW, because Burlington County Footlighters 2nd Stage sells out fast. Bring tissues if you’re lucky enough to get a ticket! Review the content before buying tickets for young adults. This show discusses some heavy stuff! … 22. This was one of the best plays I’ve ever seen in a blackbox theatre. Burlington County Footlighters 2nd Stage, located in Cinnaminson, NJ, provides a more intim


Sherlock Gets a Hilarious Makeover in Ms. Holmes & Ms. Watson at Langhorne Players
by Mike McKeon You would probably be hard pressed to find someone who doesn’t recognize the name Sherlock Holmes. A name synonymous with excitement, adventure, and mystery all rolled into one. I personally, am a huge Sherlock Holmes fan. I remember reading The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle in 1892, when I was in 7th grade. I absolutely fell in love with the short stories and I read whatever else I could find in the school library related


The American Dream takes Center Stage at The Levoy with Death of a Salesman
by Abigail Williams The crushing weight of the American Dream is taking center stage in South Jersey. The Levoy Theatre kicked off their run of one of the most famous plays of all time, Death of a Salesman on October 2nd, 2026. Even if we haven’t seen the play, we’ve all heard of this masterpiece of a story. As both a first-time viewer of Death of Salesman and guest at The Levoy Theatre, I had high expectations for this legendary tragedy. Thankfully, the opening night perfor


Does Sweeney Todd at HPP Make the Cut?
by Deitra Oliver While a visit to The Demon Barber of Fleet Street may not be on your list of places to get a haircut, you will certainly want to put this show on your to-do list to kick off ‘spooky season.’ Directed by Drew Molotsky, with Abby Drexler as assistant director, Haddonfield Plays and Players brings Stephen Sondheim’s 1979 musical to glorious, murderous life. I was fortunate to attend the sold-out opening night, and the richness of the performances and the strong
bottom of page
