top of page

A Bloody Good Time: Evil Dead: The Musical

Oct 25
6 min read

by Lucinda Fisher Alvarez


There are musicals that aim to move an audience, musicals that inspire, and musicals that simply invite everyone to sit back and enjoy the ride. In Death’s Company’s Evil Dead: The Musical at Kelsey Theatre falls firmly into the third category and that is precisely where its appeal lies. Combining campy horror, outrageous humor, energetic musical numbers, and plenty of theatrical bloodshed, this production delivers an entertaining evening that embraces the wonderfully ridiculous nature of its source material.


Based on the Evil Dead film franchise, the musical follows Ash and his friends as a trip to a remote cabin turns into a supernatural nightmare. When the group encounters the mysterious Book of the Dead, their getaway quickly descends into demonic chaos. The show never takes itself too seriously, and this production understands that its success depends on performers committing fully to the humor, music, and madness.


The cast brings an enthusiastic, playful spirit to the production, with Dan Keyser as Ash emerging as the standout performer. His performance is phenomenal, capturing the larger-than-life personality and comedic appeal that makes Ash the center of this increasingly chaotic adventure. Keyser provides a strong focal point for the production, balancing the character’s reactions to the supernatural mayhem with the confidence and energy needed to carry the show’s comic momentum. His performance is a highlight of the evening and gives the audience a compelling character to follow as the story spirals out of control.


Frank Ferrara as Jake contributes to the show’s irreverent humor as the local guide who becomes entangled in the group’s increasingly disastrous circumstances. His featured numbers, including “Good Old Reliable Jake” and “Ode to an Accidental Stabbing,” exemplify the musical’s willingness to turn even the most outrageous developments into comedy. Jake’s place in the unfolding chaos adds another dimension to the story, and Ferrara helps sustain its deliberately absurd tone.


Connor Riley plays Scott, Ash’s brash friend whose personality and involvement in the supernatural events help propel the action forward. Scott’s interactions with Ash provide opportunities for the show’s irreverent dialogue and humor, particularly in “What the Fuck Was That.” Riley contributes to the ensemble’s energetic dynamic, helping establish the relationships that make the characters’ increasingly unfortunate circumstances entertaining.


Pat Rounds portrays Ed, whose involvement in the unfolding nightmare leads to one of the production’s particularly playful musical moments, “Bit Part Demon.” The number reflects the show’s delight in poking fun at horror conventions and transforming frightening developments into theatrical comedy. Rounds helps build the ensemble’s collective sense of absurdity, which is essential to the musical’s appeal.


Maria Aromando plays Cheryl, Ash’s sister, whose encounter with the supernatural helps set the story’s mayhem in motion. Her featured numbers, including “It Won’t Let Us Leave” and “Look Who’s Evil Now,” mark the transition from an ordinary cabin getaway to a full-blown horror-comedy. Cheryl’s increasingly disturbing circumstances are central to the show’s escalating chaos, and Aromando contributes to the production’s blend of exaggerated horror and humor.


Lizzie Axler portrays Annie, whose connection to the mystery surrounding the Book of the Dead brings another layer to the story. Her number “All the Men in My Life Keep Getting Killed by Candarian Demons” perfectly captures the musical’s irreverent approach to its supernatural premise. Annie’s involvement expands the story beyond Ash and his friends, while Axler helps bring the character’s place in this increasingly ridiculous situation to the stage.


Abigail Valerio plays Linda, Ash’s girlfriend, whose presence initially provides a sense of normalcy before the supernatural events take over. Her musical interactions with Ash, including “Housewares Employee,” contribute to the show’s comic storytelling and establish the relationship at the heart of some of the ensuing chaos. Emma Tilley portrays Shelly, another of the group’s unfortunate cabin companions, helping complete the ensemble of characters whose ill-fated getaway becomes anything but relaxing.


Matthew Hogeland as Fake Shemp adds another layer of theatrical absurdity. The role embraces the musical’s playful relationship with horror-film conventions, incorporating the kind of unconventional character work that helps distinguish this show from a traditional horror story. Together, the cast creates the lively ensemble atmosphere that the material demands. The production’s humor depends on broad characterization, physical comedy, and performers willing to commit wholeheartedly to the outrageous premise, and the company embraces that spirit.


Haley Schmalbach serves as both director and choreographer, bringing a unified creative vision to the production. The staging recognizes that Evil Dead: The Musical is first and foremost a horror-comedy, allowing its humor to remain central without losing sight of the story. Character interactions, physical movement, and theatrical effects are coordinated to support the escalating action, while the choreography is well staged and well rehearsed. In a show where comic timing and coordinated movement are essential, that preparation helps maintain the pace and keeps the action entertaining. Schmalbach’s direction allows the production to embrace the material’s deliberately exaggerated style rather than attempting to make it more conventional.


Sue den Outer serves as musical director and conductor, leading a live band featuring Steve Miller on guitar, Thomas Lewis on bass, and Aaron Allen on drums. The rock-influenced score gives the musical its distinctive sound, while the irreverent lyrics turn the characters’ increasingly absurd circumstances into opportunities for comic storytelling. Numbers such as “Cabin in the Woods,” “I’m Not a Killer,” and “Do the Necronomicon” help move the story forward while reinforcing its campy horror atmosphere. The live accompaniment adds energy to the performance and supports the musical’s identity as a rock-driven comedy. Eric Collins is credited with sound, an important element in balancing vocals, instrumental accompaniment, and dialogue in a production where comic timing matters so much.


Ian Smith’s set design provides a functional and appropriate environment for the action. The cabin setting needs to accommodate the characters’ arrival, their interactions, and the increasingly supernatural events that follow. The scenic design supports those demands without distracting from the performers, giving the production a suitable backdrop for its escalating mayhem. Scenic painting by Schmalbach, Dekota Homer, and Shawn Simmons contributes to the visual environment, complementing Smith’s design and helping establish the world in which the story unfolds.


Judi Parrish’s lighting design establishes the atmosphere appropriate to a horror-inspired musical, supporting the shifts between suspenseful moments and broad comedy. Lighting is particularly important in a production that relies on fast-paced action and theatrical effects. Although the design is effective overall, some moments would benefit from greater illumination so the audience can see the main action more clearly. A few adjustments to focus and intensity could improve visibility without sacrificing the eerie atmosphere. This is a relatively specific area for improvement in an otherwise entertaining production.


The costumes and makeup are effective and contribute significantly to the show’s visual appeal. The contrast between ordinary characters and their increasingly supernatural circumstances is central to the musical’s comic-horror aesthetic, and these elements help bring that transformation to life. Props, managed by Kelly Plexico, and puppets, overseen by Lexi Plexico, also support the production’s exaggerated theatrical world. These details are especially important in a musical that depends on supernatural occurrences, visual surprises, and an enthusiastic embrace of the ridiculous.


The stage blood is particularly memorable, turning the show’s exaggerated violence into part of the theatrical spectacle. The splash zone in the front rows adds another dimension to the experience, making audience proximity to the action part of the fun. It is a distinctive feature of the musical and a fitting match for its outrageous premise. Rather than treating the effects as incidental, the production incorporates them into the overall entertainment, giving the audience a clear sense of what makes Evil Dead: The Musical such an unconventional theatrical experience.


Behind the scenes, the production benefits from a team responsible for coordinating the many elements required to bring this ambitious comedy to the stage. Pat Maliwat serves as stage manager, with Zhi Sharpe and Jo Wymer as assistant stage managers. Their roles are particularly important in a production that relies on carefully coordinated movement, musical cues, and theatrical effects. Evan Strain serves on crew, while Ben Fried is technical assistant, contributing to the practical execution of the production.


Schmalbach and Lauren Fogarty serve as producers, with Tom Hessman as executive producer. Fogarty and Riley handle marketing, helping bring attention to the production, while Zack Lozowski serves as photographer, documenting the company’s work. Alongside the performers and designers, these team members contribute to the coordination that makes a lively, technically demanding musical possible. The combined work of the creative, production, and technical teams provides the foundation for the evening’s entertainment.


Ultimately, Evil Dead: The Musical at Kelsey Theatre succeeds by embracing the spirit of its material. The energetic cast, Schmalbach’s creative direction, well-rehearsed choreography, effective set and costumes, and gleefully excessive stage effects combine to create an enjoyable theatrical experience. Keyser’s phenomenal performance as Ash is a particular highlight, while the ensemble contributes the enthusiasm and comic commitment necessary to sustain the show’s outrageous premise.


The technical elements generally support the production well, particularly the use of stage blood and the memorable splash zone. The lighting is effective overall, although greater illumination during certain scenes would improve the audience’s view of the main action. These refinements aside, the production understands what makes the musical work and delivers the entertainment its audience is likely seeking.


Theatre does not always have to be serious to be successful. Sometimes its greatest pleasure comes from performers committing completely to an outrageous premise and inviting the audience to join them. With its blend of rock music, irreverent humor, campy horror, and gloriously excessive stage effects, In Death’s Company’s Evil Dead: The Musical delivers a bloody good time. For fans of horror-comedy and audiences looking for an unconventional night at the theatre, this production is irreverent, energetic, and unapologetically theatrical—a killer combination.


Evil Dead: The Musical runs through November 1, 2026 and tickets can be purchased at https://www.purplepass.com/events/375469-evil-dead-oct-23rd-2026 




 
 
Latest Posts
bottom of page