Clear Away the Cobwebs and the Sorrow in the Levoy’s Production of Annie
by Ellorah Maeve

The opportunity to see this musical classic, Annie, is always an enjoyable experience. This is especially true at The Levoy Theatre. Having the opportunity to give gifts to castmates, buy concessions, and even specialty themed cocktails make the night even more magical. The musical Annie is about the titular character, an eleven year-old orphan girl who finds herself in the mansion of billionaire Oliver Warbucks to spend the holidays. There are many songs such as “Tomorrow”, “Fully Dressed”, and “Hard Knock Life” that are staples of modern musical theatre. Annie is a great introduction to theatre as well as a show that even seasoned theatre-goers can enjoy.
Cadey Laning as the titular character Annie is a very talented actress. Her passion and love for this show is evident in her performance in “Tomorrow.” Laning brings positivity and hope that perfectly encapsulates Annie, a memorable character. She stays professional and calm when handling the dog Jovi (Sandy) with the help of dog-handler Bobby Johnson. Hannah Lee Defrates as Grace Farrell showcases her beautiful soprano notes and the character’s gentle nature. Her solos in “I Think I’m Gonna Like It Here” and “N.Y.C.” are some prominent moments. The famous solo in “N.Y.C.” from Lorraina Hutchinson as Star to Be is another lovely moment in the musical number. Sal Sanzo as Oliver Warbucks gives many layers to the billionaire. His performance of “Something Was Missing” is a moving and heartfelt performance. Athan Rhoads gives an unforgettable performance of Miss Hannigan. They bring an expert blend of camp and their unique vocals to their take on the song “Little Girls.” Nicko Chryssomitis as Rooster brings sleazy charisma to the role and his farmer disguise during the final scenes is hilarious to watch. Lillian Larabee as Lily St. Regis brings a ditsy, dynamic energy which rounds out the trio in the song “Easy Street.” Watching these actors play up the dramatics makes for a perfect cast of villains.
Richard Curico as FDR is a prime example of character study. He is truly a master class in understanding what role he is portraying: even his singing reflected the president’s cadence. Steven Ciapanna as Lt. Ward/Bert Healy/Ickes plays up the vaudeville style during “Fully Dressed.” The performance is nostalgic for the time period; which is emphasized by the beautiful three-part harmonies of Zoey McKay, Ella Martynick and Marissa Wheaton as the Boylan Sisters. Mason Hemphill, Jacob Graves, Mya Pesantes, Olivia Caez, and Collin Lungu flesh out the rest of the ensemble and truly bring the world of Annie to life. “Hooverville” is my favorite ensemble number, and the cast gave the song comedic and poignant beats that make the number extremely engaging to watch. The waitstaff of Mr. Warbucks is rounded out by adult ensemble as well; with some outstanding actors Michael Palmreuter as Drake (and also Bundles), Megan Peek as Mrs. Greer (and also Perkins), and Julia Hahn as Mrs. Pugh (as well as Sophie and Howe).
I have never seen young actors so engaged and expressive onstage. The orphans showcase so many talents which include tap, tumbling stunts and beautiful harmonies during “Hard Knock Life” and “Fully Dressed.” Each orphan is a unique character, and it makes one empathetic to their struggles of life in the orphanage. It is important to note that the child casts are split between a Gold and Red cast. I had the privilege to watch the Gold cast, and highly encourage anyone to find a chance to watch both casts perform. All of these kids are immensely talented and deserve all of the accolades. The Gold cast consists of Cadey Laning as Annie, Lucy Musterel as Duffy, Jayda Ashley as July, Gia Cotellese as Kate, Mirabelle Socha as Molly, Tessa Davidson as Pepper, and Sophia Cayer-Johnson as Tessie. The Red cast consists of Avery Forbes as Annie, Katherine Peek as Duffy, Natalia Mateo as July, Alessia Gallo as Kate, Maia Petrongio as Molly, Sunny Barson as Pepper, and Molly Klinetob as Tessie.
Director Maura Mather and Assistant Director Lea Weiner help give strong guidance to the actors and create a wonderful version of Annie that will stick with audiences for years to come. Mather is also Scenic Designer, and helps create a beautiful New York skyline. The way she strategically has the different settings conceptualized, with the collaboration of Set Builder Michael Blandino and Set Painter Jeanne Marie Rambo, makes scene changes appear flawless and easy for castmates to maneuver. With expert backdrop lighting from the Lighting Designer Lindsay Stevens, she uses dynamic lighting during “Tomorrow” that is reminiscent of sunlight and a bright future, which adds to the song’s powerful message. I can only imagine the challenges Stage Manager Patty Davis had to face when dealing with an adult cast as well as the youth cast. Huge kudos to Davis for keeping the theatre machine moving. Musical Director Stephen Sheftz does a fantastic job punching great harmony lines in the songs “New Deal for Christmas” and “Cabinet Tomorrow.” Zoey McKay as choreographer brings out dynamite performances from the orphans during “Hard Knock Life” and “Fully Dressed.”
Sound Designer Robert Tucker gives a fun blend of ‘live’ sound effects in the radio station scene as well as other ambient noises like police sirens and street traffic. Costumers Lisa Zeigler & Nancy Cervino/The Masquerade Ball create the 1930’s silhouette expertly and pick wonderful skirts that twirl beautifully when the dancers spin. The wait staff’s outfits and the Hooverville outfits really immerse the audience into the world of Annie. Hair & Makeup Designer Hannah Green creates beautiful wig work and dynamic make up that heightens the facial expressions of the actors onstage. Props provided by the Levoy, cast, families and staff truly brings to light the amount of care and love that is put into this production of Annie. With the help of the technical staff as well as the efforts of Production Assistant Brayden McPherson, Annie is truly a high quality production that is an enjoyable experience for all ages.
During the cast meet and greet after the show, I had the opportunity to ask Cadey Laning what she loved most about being Annie. She told me that she grew up watching the musical Annie and absolutely loves this timeless classic. This musical teaches us all that hope is the most powerful tool to have. Regardless of social class, political background, and identity, there is always an opportunity . If we were all like Annie, always moving towards a better future and keeping a positive outlook, the world would be a better place to live for all. The production of Annie at the Levoy Theatre will be running from November 13th through November 22nd. Tickets are available at the following link: https://levoy.net/events/category/series/annie/the-levoy-theatre/millville-new-jersey/






