1776: A Nation Divided, A Future Undecided at the Kelsey Theatre
by Michael McKeon

I hate to bring politics into any conversation, let alone one of my reviews for South Jersey Theatre Critics (SJTC). However, I think if there was ever a time to do so, the justified opportunity would be during my review of 1776 The Musical. 1776 The Musical, I saw for the first time on Saturday Afternoon. Performed inside Kelsey Theatre at Mercer Community College, produced by Theater To Go and directed by Ruth Markoe. Stage Managed by Christine Heffron with Assistant Stage Manager Rachel Piscopo. I had heard of this show many times before and, as a fan of history, it seemed important for me to see. I must say watching this performance and remembering where it all started felt even more significant given the fact that the recent Mid-term Elections for Congress and Senate heeded tremendously enlightened results across our country!!!
I love the authenticity added to a performance when it has a live orchestra present. I must give credit to the talented musicians first. Conductor/Keyboard (Sue den Outer), Keyboard 2 (Zachary Barton), Trumpet (Laura Neville), Percussion (Eric Ficarra), Reed (Jean Gould), Bass (Thomas Lewis), Horn (Lisa Peterson), Violin (Anthony Wong, Peter Pezzino & Rusty Stauffer). These musicians did an amazing job for the duration of this almost 3 hour performance.
The stage was simple but worked perfectly for the large stage size and accompanying large cast. An imitation of Congress Hall, complete with a real voting board and makeshift windows, is utilized in the back of the stage during debates. When we are not in the halls of Congress a screen is lowered in front of the set and a projection of the capitol building is in the background. This simple yet clever set design is credited to Ian Smith. Also at the beginning of the show, during “Sit Down, John”, while most members of the cast were on stage, the audience had the opportunity to see the full wardrobe of the cast and it was not disappointing. Not only were the hair and costumes period appropriate, but they were very well done. Melissa Rittman deserves all credit for a fantastic job on costumes. Not only was that opening number colorful from wardrobe, but also from the lively performance itself. Much praise to Musical Director Sue den Outer and Choreographer Haley Schmalbach.
Once the show starts we are introduced to John Adams (Patrick Lavery) addressing different members of congress. It is established very early on that Adams is obnoxious and disliked by most of his peers. Lavery does an amazing job portraying this. His condescending tone and dismissive attitude toward those he disagrees with, leaves no question as to why his character is disliked. However this tough persona shifts slightly when John Adams thinks about and sings with his wife Abigail Adams (Cecelia Tepping). Tepping and Lavery’s voices shine as they show how much they love each other while singing “Till Then,” revealing John’s soft side.
The next important figure we are introduced to is Benjamin Franklin (Donald Hallcom) as he is giving John Adams some advice for his strategy in the fight for independence. Hallcom portrays Benjamin Franklin as a wise mentor to Adams and maintains that attitude consistently throughout the performance. There was a moment, when Franklin was speaking with Adams, Hallcom forgot a line and seemed to almost panic. Lavery confidently grabbed his leg as he sat beside him and quickly guided him to the next line. I took note of this, not only because it was a very professional recovery by both of them, but there was a true kindness behind the gesture from Lavery and I think it was a big part of the reason they could continue on so smoothly.
Franklin and Adams introduce us to the next important character Richard Henry Lee played by Tammy Tuckey. Tuckey provides more than enough energy for this role. From the moment Tuckey touches the stage you are entertained with every scene they are present. Franklin and Adams conspire with Lee to attempt to turn votes for independence currently being debated in Congress.
During Act One there is a debate and we meet other Members of Congress. Firstly, is drunken Stephen Hopkins (Barry Leonard) of Rhode Island voting for independence. His physical humor was perfect for an unruly drunk. Hopkins introduces us to Andrew McNair (Phil Zipkin) , the custodian of congress and Secretary of Congress Charles Thomson (James Zimmerman). Tending to their needs for anything from receiving messages, closing/opening the windows to fetching Hopkins more whiskey. I must say one of my favorite details of the show was how McNair would mumble under his breath at the request to open the window, after already closing due to complaints of flies only moments earlier. McNair actively used the voting board to keep track of which Colonies voted in favor, or against, independence from Britain and the King. I thought it was a clever interaction by director Ruth Markoe, and helped keep track of the storyline.
This scene was very entertaining as the congressmen debated the pros and cons of independence and interrupted each other whenever possible. We quickly meet the flamboyant representative from South Carolina Edward Rutledge (William Kamps) whose demeanor superbly matches his outfit. North Carolina representative Joseph Hewes (Joseph Stockette) comically followed in Rutledge’s shadow both politically and figuratively by agreeing with, and never disputing where they stood based on South Carolina’s political stance. There are countless other times members of the congress stood out as they debated, but there were far too many to list in only one review article.
Other members of the delegation involved in the debate are as follows: Lyman Hall of Georgia (Steve Vardy), Thomas McKean of Delaware (Stan Karuzis), Caesar Rodney of Delaware (Norm Politziner), John Dickinson of Pennsylvania (Edward Forsthoffer), James Wilson of Pennsylvania (Steve Wolfe), Head of Congress John Hancock (Jim Morris), Thomas Jefferson of Virginia (Shawn Simmons), Josiah Bartlett of New Hampshire (Robert Brown), George Read of Delaware (Carlos Najera-Gonzalez), Roger Sherman of Connecticut (Edward Liu), Lewis Morris of New York (Tim Costello), Samuel Chase of Machachussettes (Mark Shifton), John Witherspoon of New Jersey (John McCorry), and Robert Livingston of New York (Nicholas Kianka).
After this debate, Franklin and Adams are trying to convince and motivate Jefferson (Simmons) to finish the declaration. But they need to recruit some help from Martha Jefferson (Lucinda Fisher Alvarez) to get Jefferson's creative ideas flowing. While performing “He Plays the Violin” Fisher Alvarez sounds amazing proving why she was the perfect choice for this role; She and Simmon have a great chemistry together.
There were multiple times throughout the debate that messages were delivered by The Courier (Alex Ridder). If you have read any of my previous reviews you know I love props and always make sure they get respect. Well properties by Melissa Rittman, Ruth Markoe, & Edward Simmons did not disappoint! The letters being delivered looked weathered and aged like they came from the battlefield. The Courier looked a bit more tired and morale depleted each time he entered the halls of Congress. This attention to detail drew a clearer picture of the reality of what was being debated by these men.
Finishing out the Act Congress dismisses and McNair (Zipkin) invites The Courier (Ridder) to sit and rest with him and Leather Apron (Joey Violi), another Congress Custodian. Ridder performs “Momma Look Sharp” on center stage. The spotlight drops low, credit lighting design (Kitty Getlik), on Ridder while he sings with tremendous emotion. This song is so important to the show. It puts a stop to the playful mindset in place from the “Piddle, Twiddle, and Resolve” game that congress plays while they debate from the comfort of their chairs. Ridder forces the audience to face the discomfort that men were dying each day while Congressmen debated politics. His voice made it clear there was no time to debate, independence must be preserved if not for all, then it would be for none.
1776 the Musical has unfortunately completed its run. Be sure to look for future performances at www.kelseytheatre.org







