The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical at Bridge Players Theatre Company Delivers Joy
by Shirley Erwin

With holiday favorites playing overhead and audience members donning festive sweaters, the Christmas ambiance hits you as soon as you step into Broad Street United Methodist Church in Burlington. The Bridge Players Theatre Company continues to celebrate its 50th Anniversary Season with a delightful production of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical. Based on the beloved book and subsequent play by Barbara Robinson, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever was adapted as a musical with book and lyrics by Jahnna Beecham and music and lyrics by Malcolm Hillgartner. The high-energy and fun - though sometimes slightly chaotic - musical numbers in The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical are sure to entertain families and audiences of all ages. The heartwarming story is an excellent reminder to take the time to understand and include others as we enter the holiday season.
Preparations for the annual Christmas pageant in The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical are underway. After an untimely accident, the usual director of the church pageant strongarms a reluctant Grace Bradley into running the show. When the “worst kids in the world” demand to be in the pageant, Grace finds herself figuring out how to wrangle the sextet of rambunctious Herdman siblings while under the harsh scrutiny of the other church ladies and entire town.
This was the first production that I have seen put on by the Bridge Players Theatre Company and several cast members also made their BPTC debut, including the leading lady Gina Drigant. Her role as Grace Bradley meant she was almost always on stage, rarely getting a break. G. Drigant masterfully conveys Grace’s growth as the plot progresses and displays strong command when singing. Her voice especially shines in “Maybe,” the touching duet with Damon A. Strothers. Strothers also adds humor to multiple scenes as the easygoing and supportive husband Bob Bradley, who tries absolutely everything to get out of attending the pageant. Desmond McMahon is outstanding as Charlie Bradley, especially in “Take My Lunch.” Charlie finally decides to stand up to the bullying Herdmans by bragging about snacks at Sunday school, inadvertently alerting them to the existence of the church and the pageant.
Azalea Williams exceptionally rounds out the family as Charlie’s older sister Beth Bradley, who is balancing the delicate dynamic between fitting in with her peers and backing her mother. Williams’ “My Mother Said” cleverly sung to the tune of the holiday classic “Carol of the Bells” along with Jessica Gripp’s Alice Wendleken and Layna Watson’s Ivy Reed was one of my favorite songs. The talented church children also include Amelia Davis as the pastor’s kid Elmer Hopkins, Aubrey Shoultz as the inquisitive Teddy Shoemaker, and young Jade Allen in her first show.
The Herdmans - Rob Drigant as Ralph, Arya McMahon as Imogene, Jocelyn Womack as Leroy, Lexi Watson as Claude, Gabriel Napier as Ollie, and Lylah Watson as Gladys - brought their rowdiness every time they were on stage. It was even impossible to tell whether their antics were intentional or accidental. R. Drigant has a huge stage presence as the oldest and loudest Herdman. A. McMahon expertly portrays both the tough and sensitive sides of Imogene, particularly as Mary in “On A Night Like This” during the pageant. Lylah Watson knows how to be in the spotlight and clearly enjoys it despite being the youngest Herdman.
The adult ensemble includes Jay Fink, gracing the stage in his first BPTC show as Reverend Hopkins. Amber Stolarski demonstrates her powerful voice while confined to a wheelchair as the injured Helen Armstrong. Anjelica McMahon (Luanne), Marissa DiPilla (Betty), and Eva Kleinlein (Connie) are a triple threat as the lovely church ladies.
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical is directed and choreographed by Jo Piazza assisted by the Vocal Director is Steve McMahon. Kate Petrovich, as the Stage Manager, assisted by Nathan Hill, ensured that the production ran well. The lighting design by Bob Beaucheane was executed perfectly by lighting technicians Phil Aaronson and Jaden Murray. The minimalist set design by Ken Kauker, Kris Kauker (also the Sound Designer), and Jo Piazza allowed for multiple numbers with chaotic running children. The cast was nicely dressed by Costume Designer Kat Fresh and the Company Costume Manager Jackie Reinhart for both the musical and the pageant. The various props ranging from holiday decorations to corded telephones to food donation baskets were provided by Jo Piazza.
The live music was provided by a small pit orchestra, expertly led by Jim Sheffer. The phenomenal musicians playing throughout the show, even between scenes, include Sam Brooks (reeds), Sadie Smith (alto sax), Talia Fisher (keyboard), Amy Fleming (guitar), Dave Kaplan (bass), and JC Nicdao (drums).
Although the source material is from 1972, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical communicates why stories must continue to be told and passed on, while also keeping in mind that all stories - even the Christmas story - can be interpreted differently when viewed through fresh eyes. The enduring themes of patience, acceptance, and understanding resonate with all generations. Be sure to take all your loved ones to The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical at Bridge Players Theatre Company for an uplifting, joyful, and heartfelt holiday show.
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever: The Musical is running from November 13th to November 28th, 2026 with Friday/Saturday performances at 8 pm and Sunday performances at 3 pm. There is also a special Saturday matinee on November 21st. Tickets are available here: https://www.tix.com/ticket-sales/BridgePlayers/7570






