top of page
South Jersey Theatre Critics is an independent volunteer organization dedicated to providing thoughtful, honest reviews of community theatre throughout South Jersey and the Greater Philadelphia region.
Since May 2023, our team of 23 volunteer reviewers has published more than 220 reviews covering productions at 28 theatre organizations.
LATEST REVIEWS


“The Truth” Ev'rybody Gotta Know; Is Reefer Madness at Cumberland Players Will Have You Laughing “High” In the Rafters!
by Ellorah Maeve Reefer Madness started as a movie from the late 1930’s. The film was made as a tried and true public service announcement and propaganda. Now, this PSA is turned into a dark musical satire; written by Kevin Murphy and Dan Studney and speaks on the dangers of propaganda and nationalism. This shift from the unknown to the absurd makes for a hilarious night that you would not want to miss. Sober or not, seeing this production truly feels like you are hooked on
3 days ago6 min read


A Hilarious and Chaotic Trip to The Playmasters Theatre Workshop: The Cottage is Laughter Guaranteed!
by Abby Williams On Friday, June 12th, The Playmasters Theatre Workshop opened its final production of the 2025-2026 season, The Cottage. Written by Sandy Rustin, The Cottage is a hilarious comedic farce full of scandal, charm, and twists and turns galore! Our setting is the English countryside in 1923, where chaos is set in motion when Sylvia (Colleen Mackle) decides to expose her affair to both her husband and to her lover’s wife. After its limited run on Broadway in 2023,
Jun 154 min read


Finding Community Between the Pages: A Review of “Read Me” at Queertre
by Michael McKeon This past Sunday South Jersey Theatre Critics (SJTC) was invited to review a new original show, by a new original theatre company, from a very new location. Normally I start my reviews by exclaiming about how great (or not so great) the show I just went to see was. Sometimes I insist on detailing the beautiful architecture and elegant history of the theatres in which the performance is being held. Other times I jump straight into how remarkable the stage d
Jun 124 min read


Horton Hears A Hit – A Review of Seussical The Musical at Kelsey Theatre
by Angela Robb As an early childhood educator, I continually find myself returning to the works of Dr. Seuss. His stories are timeless and filled with playful language and memorable characters. Characters like Horton the Elephant, The Grinch, The Lorax, and The Cat in the Hat are recognized and beloved by multiple generations. While I have read Seuss’s works regularly as a child and shared them with countless children over the years, I have never seen Seussical the Musical u
Jun 99 min read


No Dice — It's Delightful at Gateway Playhouse
by Devion Watson Musical theatre has a way of pulling you into a completely different world, and Guys and Dolls at Gateway Playhouse did exactly that. From the moment the show began, it was clear this production was going to be full of energy, humor, and heart. Frank Loesser’s classic score combined with strong performances from the cast made for a really enjoyable night at the theatre. As someone who already loves Guys and Dolls, I had high expectations going in, especiall
Jun 76 min read


As the saying goes… “Big Fish, Small Pond” at PCS
by Sarah Dorsey Daniel Wallace’s 1998 novel Big Fish tells the tale about a father with larger than life stories, Edward Bloom, and his son, William Bloom, a realist and matter of fact story teller. As William prepares for the arrival of his own son, he sets out to find the truth of his father’s past. Gradually, he realizes that his father’s over the top, mythic stories weren’t necessarily to frustrate him but to teach him about people and life’s greatest challenges. Players
Jun 15 min read


There is Nothing Wimpy About Diary of a Wimpy Kid at The Levoy Theatre
by Deitra Oliver with Guests: Jude (Age 12) and Kendrick (Age 9) Middle school isn’t for the faint of heart. Things like popularity, the Cheese Touch, and the numbers 6 and 7 reign supreme in the hallowed halls of every middle school. My personal recollections of my time there, honestly not that long ago, are fuzzy at best. Since I am not the most reliable source on all things middle school, I brought my nephews, Jude and Kendrick, along with me to see Diary of a Wimpy Kid
May 208 min read


Glengarry Glen Ross: These People are Insane, They Just Like Talking to Salesmen
by Michael McKeon One consistent hassle in life we can all agree on, regardless of your own personal demographic, is that dealing with salesmen is a necessary evil. Whether it be buying a car, a home, or hell even a cell phone you must sit down at the table and play the game. Then you must decide if this person on the other side of the table is genuine or has a motive. How can you get the best deal? Should you look somewhere else for a better price? The Blue Moon Theatre
May 194 min read


Summertime, and the Reviewing Is Easy: Gershwins’ Porgy and Bess at The Ritz
by Deitra Oliver Gershwins’ Porgy and Bess, presented by The Ritz Theatre Company, directed by Darryl S. Thompson, Jr., is nothing short of a triumph. Set in a fictional African-American tenement called Catfish Row in Charleston, South Carolina, during the early 1920’s, the folk opera tells the story of Porgy, played by Stephan Burse, a disabled black man forced to live as a beggar, and his unlikely love affair with the free-spirited Bess, played by Erica Imani Liburd; both
May 1910 min read
bottom of page
